objective-cinheritanceimportforward-declaration

"Attempting to use the forward class 'Game' as superclass of 'MathGame'" in Cocos2d


I'm making a Cocos2d game for iphone, and I have my main game mode, Game, which inherits from CCLayer.

I'm trying to make another game mode, MathGame, which inherits from Game, but when I try to compile, I get this error in MathGame.h:

Attempting to use the forward class 'Game' as superclass of 'MathGame'

I get the error even if the implementation and interface of MathGame are empty. And it only happens if I try to include MathGame.h in another file.

Here's the code for the Game class:

// Game.h
#import "cocos2d.h"
#import <GameKit/GameKit.h>
#import "SplashScreenLayer.h"

@interface Game : CCLayer
    // A bunch of stuff
@end

The new game type:

// MathGame.h
#import "Game.h"

@interface MathGame : Game
@end

And the main menu that includes both:

// SplashScreen.h
#import "cocos2d.h"
#import "Game.h"
#import "MathGame.h"
#import "HowToPlayLayer.h"
#import "AboutLayer.h"

@interface SplashScreenLayer : CCLayer
    // A bunch of stuff
@end

I can't find anything helpful online. Any ideas?


Solution

  • You simply have an import cycle:

    1. Game imports SplashScreenLayer
    2. SplashScreenLayer imports MathGame
    3. MathGame imports Game

    Your solution:

    Leave the import inside the MathGame, and change the other imports to @class.

    To sum it up:

    // Game.h
    #import "cocos2d.h"
    #import <GameKit/GameKit.h>
    
    @class SplashScreenLayer;
    @interface Game : CCLayer
        // A bunch of stuff
    @end
    
    The new game type:
    
    // MathGame.h
    #import "Game.h"
    
    @interface MathGame : Game
    @end
    
    And the main menu that includes both:
    
    // SplashScreen.h
    #import "cocos2d.h"
    #import "HowToPlayLayer.h"
    #import "AboutLayer.h"
    
    @class Game;
    @class MathGame;
    @interface SplashScreenLayer : CCLayer
        // A bunch of stuff
    @end
    

    With your question answered above, let me explain a few things I already know from reading about forward declerations and import cycles:

    First, go read about them! They are a very important part of Objective-C, and you don't want to miss it!

    Secondly, use @class whenever you need that class for private variables or method parameters. Use imports for inheritance and strong properties.

    Thirdly, don't forget to #import your forwarded classes in the implementation file!