sqljoinon-clause

How do constant values effect the ON clause of Joins?


I've recently discovered that the ON clause of a LEFT JOIN may contain values such as (1 = 1).

This is upsetting to me, as it breaks my perception of how joins function.

I've encountered a more elaborate version of the following situation:

SELECT DISTINCT Person.ID, ...
FROM Person LEFT JOIN Manager 
ON (Manager.ID = Person.ID OR Manager.ID = -1))
WHERE (...)

It's perfectly legal. What does "Manager.ID = -1" accomplish, if anything? How can this effect the Join?


Solution

  • If person table is:

    id  name
    
    1   Person One
    2   Person Two
    3   Person Three
    4   Person Four
    5   Person Five
    

    If manager table is

    id  name
    -1  Admin
    2   Manager One
    3   Manager Two
    

    if the query is:

    SELECT DISTINCT *
    FROM Person LEFT JOIN Manager 
    ON (Manager.id = Person.id OR Manager.id = -1)
    

    Then the result is:

    Person One  -1  Admin
    Person Two  -1  Admin
    Person Two  2   Manager One
    Person Three    -1  Admin
    Person Three    3   Manager Two
    Person Four -1  Admin
    Person Five -1  Admin
    

    Here all person rows joins with the -1 Admin (on manager table) AND if the same id exist in manager table one more join occurs.