scalascala-collectionsscala-option

Summing up two options


Let's say I have two optional Ints (both can be Some or None):

val one : Option[Int] = Some(1)
val two : Option[Int] = Some(2)

My question is the following: Are there any intelligent way to sum them op using Scalas brilliant collection-methods? I realize that I could merge them into a collection, flatten it and use reduceLeftOption like so:

(one :: two :: Nil).flatten.reduceLeftOption(_ + _)     // Some(3)

But, the solution above means creating a new collection, and living in a rich and developed world that takes time from all the other first world activities I might immerse myself into. And in a world where programming gets more and more luxurious for programmers like us, there must be one or more luxurious first world answer(s) to this, right?

Edit: So to spell things out, here are some examples:

If one = Some(1) and two = Some(2) we should have Some(3)

If one = Some(1) and two = None we should have Some(1)

If one = None and two = Some(2) we should have Some(2)

If both one and two are None we should have None, since neither one or two can be summed correctly.

Hope that clarified things :-)


Solution

  • obligatory scalaz answer is to use the scalaz Option monoid:

    scala> one |+| two
    res0: Option[Int] = Some(3)
    

    It will do what you want with respect to None:

    scala> two |+| None
    res1: Option[Int] = Some(2)
    
    scala> none[Int] |+| none[Int]
    res2: Option[Int] = None
    

    That none method is a method from scalaz which helps with type inference because instead of returning None <: Option[Nothing] it returns a Option[Int], there is a similar method from Some which returns an Option[A] for any given A instead of a Some[A]:

    scala> 1.some |+| 2.some
    res3: Option[Int] = Some(3)