c++rvaluetemporaries

Are all temporaries rvalues in C++?


I have been coding in C++ for past few years. But there is one question that I have not been able to figure out. I want to ask, are all temporaries in C++, rvalues?

If no, can anyone provide me an example where temporary produced in the code is an lvalue?


Solution

  • No.

    The C++ language specification never makes such a straightforward assertion as the one you are asking about. It doesn't say anywhere in the language standard that "all temporary objects are rvalues". Moreover, the question itself is a bit of misnomer, since the property of being an rvalue in the C++ language is not a property of an object, but rather a property of an expression (i.e. a property of its result). This is actually how it is defined in the language specification: for different kinds of expressions it says when the result is an lvalue and when it is an rvalue. Among other things, this actually means that a temporary object can be accessed as an rvalue as well as an lvalue, depending on the specific form of expression that is used to perform the access.

    For example, the result of literal 2 + 3 expression is obviously an rvalue, a temporary of type int. We cannot apply the unary & to it since unary & requires an lvalue as its operand

    &(2 + 3); // ERROR, lvalue required
    

    However, as we all know, a constant reference can be attached to a temporary object, as in

    const int &ri = 2 + 3;
    

    In this case the reference is attached to the temporary, extending the lifetime of the latter. Obviously, once it is done, we have access to that very same temporary as an lvalue ri, since references are always lvalues. For example, we can easily and legally apply the unary & to the reference and obtain a pointer to the temporary

    const int *pi = &ri;
    

    with that pointer remaining perfectly valid as long as the temporary persists.

    Another obvious example of lvalue access to a temporary object is when we access a temporary object of class type through its this pointer. The result of *this is an lvalue (as is always the case with the result of unary * applied to a data pointer), yet it doesn't change the fact that the actual object might easily be a temporary. For a given class type T, expression T() is an rvalue, as explicitly stated in the language standard, yet the temporary object accessed through *T().get_this() expression (with the obvious implementation of T::get_this()) is an lvalue. Unlike the previous example, this method allows you to immediately obtain a non-const-qualified lvalue, which refers to a temporary object.

    So, once again, the very same temporary object might easily be "seen" as an rvalue or as an lvalue depending on what kind of expression (what kind of access path) you use to "look" at that object.