I'm looking for recommendations for HTML pretty printers which fulfill the following requirements:
Have a look at the HTML Tidy Project: http://www.html-tidy.org/
The granddaddy of HTML tools, with support for modern standards.
There used to be a fork called tidy-html5 which since became the official thing. Here is its GitHub repository.
Tidy is a console application for Mac OS X, Linux, Windows, UNIX, and more. It corrects and cleans up HTML and XML documents by fixing markup errors and upgrading legacy code to modern standards.
For your needs, here is the command line to call Tidy:
tidy inputfile.html