gitrebasemerge-conflict-resolution

git rebase, keeping track of 'local' and 'remote'

When doing a git rebase, I often have difficulty working out what is happening with the 'local' and 'remote' when resolving conflicts. I sometimes have the impression that they swap sides from one commit to the next.

This is probably (definitely) because I still don't properly understand the paradigm.

When rebasing, who is 'local' and who is 'remote'?

(I use P4Merge for resolving conflicts.)

Solution

  • TL;DR;

    To summarize (As Benubird comments):

    When resolving conflicts during:

    git checkout A
git rebase B   # rebase A onto B

    When resolving conflicts during:

    git checkout A
git merge B    # merge B into A

    In short:

    LOCAL always means "the branch that stays where it is"
    REMOTE always means "the branch that is being moved or merged in"

    kutschkem points out that, in a GUI mergetool context:

    See illustrations in the last part of this answer.

    Inversion when rebase

    The confusion might be related to the inversion of ours and theirs during a rebase.
    (relevant extracts)

    git rebase man page:

    Note that a rebase merge works by replaying each commit from the working branch on top of the <upstream> branch.

    Because of this, when a merge conflict happens:

    Inversion illustrated

    On a merge

    x--x--x--x--x(*) <- current branch B ('*'=HEAD)
    \
     \
      \--y--y--y <- other branch to merge

    , we don't change the current branch 'B', so what we have is still what we were working on (and we merge from another branch)

    x--x--x--x--x---------o(*)  MERGE, still on branch B
    \       ^        /
     \     ours     /
      \            /
       --y--y--y--/  
               ^
              their

    On a rebase:

    But on a rebase, we switch side because the first thing a rebase does is to checkout the upstream branch! (to replay the current commits on top of it)

    x--x--x--x--x(*) <- current branch B
    \
     \
      \--y--y--y <- upstream branch

    A git rebase upstream will first change HEAD of B to the upstream branch HEAD (hence the switch of 'ours' and 'theirs' compared to the previous "current" working branch.)

    x--x--x--x--x <- former "current" branch, new "theirs"
    \
     \
      \--y--y--y(*) <- upstream branch with B reset on it,  
                       new "ours", to replay x's on it

    , and then the rebase will replay 'their' commits on the new 'our' B branch:

    x--x..x..x..x <- old "theirs" commits, now "ghosts", available through reflogs
    \
     \
      \--y--y--y--x'--x'--x'(*) <-  branch B with HEAD updated ("ours")
               ^
               |
        upstream branch

    Note: the "upstream" notion is the referential set of data (a all repo or, like here, a branch, which can be a local branch) from which data are read or to which new data are added/created.

    'local' and 'remote' vs. 'mine' and 'theirs'

    Pandawood adds in the comments:

    For me, the question still remains, which is "local" and who is "remote" (since the terms "ours" and "theirs" are not used when rebasing in git, referring to them just seems to make an answer more confusing).

    GUI git mergetool

    kutschkem adds, and rightly so:

    When resolving conflicts, git will say something like:

    local: modified file and remote: modified file.

    I am quite sure the question aims at the definition of local and remote at this point. At that point, it seems to me from my experience that:

    git mergetool does indeed mention 'local' and 'remote':

    Merging:
f.txt

Normal merge conflict for 'f.txt':
  {local}: modified file
  {remote}: modified file
Hit return to start merge resolution tool (kdiff3):

    For instance, KDiff3 would display the merge resolution like so:

    kdiff3

    And meld would display it too:

    Meld diff

    Same for VimDiff, which displays:

    Invoke Vimdiff as a mergetool with git mergetool -t gvimdiff. Recent versions of Git invoke Vimdiff with the following window layout:

    +--------------------------------+
| LOCAL  |     BASE     | REMOTE |
+--------------------------------+
|             MERGED             |
+--------------------------------+
    • LOCAL:
      A temporary file containing the contents of the file on the current branch.

    Git has performed as much automatic conflict resolution as possible and the state of this file is a combination of both LOCAL and REMOTE with conflict markers surrounding anything that Git could not resolve itself.
    The mergetool should write the result of the resolution to this file.