mysqlsql-serverjoinjunction-table

Using SQL to join tables with a junction table


I am trying to output data from 2 different tables in my database which are joined by a junction table.

Table 1: musician
Columns: musicianID, surname, fName

Table 2: musician_band
Columns: musicianID, bandID

Table 3: band
Columns: bandID, bandName, genre, yearFormed, origin

Just to start with I want to output:

fName, bandName

I tried using this query:

SELECT DISTINCT fName, bandName
FROM musician_band
JOIN musician ON musician.musicianID = musician_band.musicianID
JOIN band ON band.bandID = band.bandID

But instead of giving me a list of musicians and the bands that they're in, it is instead repeating the first name of the first musician in the databse and then a band name on the right, this is repeated for every band in the database, even where there shouldn't be a relationship between that particular musician and band. Like this:

fname         bandName
musician1     band1
musician1     band2
musician1     band3
musician2     band1
musician2     band2
musician2     band3

etc...

How can I correct this so that it only outputs musicians in their correct bands?


Solution

  • There is a problem with your aliases. You need distinct alias for each referenced tables in your JOIN:

    This sample query would work fine:

    SELECT DISTINCT fName, bandName
    FROM @musician_band mb
    JOIN @musician m ON m.musicianID = mb.musicianID
    JOIN @band b ON mb.bandID = b.bandID
    

    Using this sample in SQL Server:

    declare @musician table(musicianID int, surname varchar(50), fName varchar(50));
    insert into @musician(musicianID, surname, fName
    ) values
    ( 1, 'Pete Doherty', 'Pete Doherty')
    , ( 2, 'Damon Albarn', 'Damon Albarn')
    
    declare @musician_band table(musicianID int, bandID int);
    insert into @musician_band(musicianID, bandID) values
    (1, 1)
    , (1, 2)
    , (2, 3)
    , (2, 4)
    
    declare @band table(bandID int, bandName varchar(50), genre varchar(50), yearFormed int, origin varchar(50));
    insert into @band(bandID, bandName, genre, yearFormed, origin
    ) values
    ( 1, 'The Libertines', '', 0, '')
    , (2, 'Babyshambles', '', 0, '')
    , (3, 'Blur', '', 0, '')
    , (4, 'Gorillaz', '', 0, '')
    

    The output is:

    fName           bandName
    Damon Albarn    Blur
    Damon Albarn    Gorillaz
    Pete Doherty    Babyshambles
    Pete Doherty    The Libertines
    

    Just replace @tablename by your own table. Is DISTINCT useful in this case?