When performing subtraction of pointers and the first pointer is less than the second, I'm getting an underflow error with the ARM processor.
Example code:
#include <stdint.h>
#include <stdbool.h>
uint8_t * p_formatted_data_end;
uint8_t formatted_text_buffer[10240];
static _Bool
Flush_Buffer_No_Checksum(void)
{
_Bool system_failure_occurred = false;
p_formatted_data_end = 0; // For demonstration puposes.
const signed int length =
p_formatted_data_end - &formatted_text_buffer[0];
if (length < 0)
{
system_failure_occurred = true;
}
//...
return true;
}
The assembly code generated by the IAR compiler is:
807 static _Bool
808 Flush_Buffer_No_Checksum(void)
809 {
\ Flush_Buffer_No_Checksum:
\ 00000000 0xE92D4070 PUSH {R4-R6,LR}
\ 00000004 0xE24DD008 SUB SP,SP,#+8
810 _Bool system_failure_occurred = false;
\ 00000008 0xE3A04000 MOV R4,#+0
811 p_formatted_data_end = 0; // For demonstration purposes.
\ 0000000C 0xE3A00000 MOV R0,#+0
\ 00000010 0x........ LDR R1,??DataTable3_7
\ 00000014 0xE5810000 STR R0,[R1, #+0]
812 const signed int length =
813 p_formatted_data_end - &formatted_text_buffer[0];
\ 00000018 0x........ LDR R0,??DataTable3_7
\ 0000001C 0xE5900000 LDR R0,[R0, #+0]
\ 00000020 0x........ LDR R1,??DataTable7_7
\ 00000024 0xE0505001 SUBS R5,R0,R1
814 if (length < 0)
\ 00000028 0xE3550000 CMP R5,#+0
\ 0000002C 0x5A000009 BPL ??Flush_Buffer_No_Checksum_0
815 {
816 system_failure_occurred = true;
\ 00000030 0xE3A00001 MOV R0,#+1
\ 00000034 0xE1B04000 MOVS R4,R0
The subtraction instruction SUBS R5,R0,R1 is equivalent to:
R5 = R0 - R1
The N bit in the CPSR register will be set if the result is negative.
Ref: Section A4.1.106 SUB of ARM Architecture Reference Manual
Let:
R0 == 0x00000000
R1 == 0x802AC6A5
Register R5 will have the value 0x7FD5395C.
The N bit of the CPSR register is 0, indicating the result is not negative.
The Windows 7 Calculator application is reporting negative, but only when expressed as 64-bits: FFFFFFFF7FD5395C.
As an experiment, I used the ptrdiff_t type for the length, and the same assembly language was generated.
Questions:
Platform:
Target Processor: ARM Cortex A8 (TI AM3358)
Compiler: IAR 7.40
Development platform: Windows 7.
Is this valid behavior, to have the result of pointer subtraction to underflow?
Yes, because the behavior in your case is undefined. Any behavior is valid there. As was observed in comments, the difference between two pointers is defined only for pointers that point to elements of the same array object, or one past the last element of the array object (C2011, 6.5.6/9).
What is the recommended data type to view the distance as negative?
Where it is defined, the result of subtracting two pointers is specified to be of type ptrdiff_t, a signed integer type of implementation-defined size. If you evaluate p1 - p2, where p1 points to an array element and p2 points to a later element of the same array, then the result will be a negative number representable as a ptrdiff_t.