mysqldatabasecachingselectquery-cache

MySQL cache of subset queries


I am attempting to make a query run on a large database in acceptable time. I'm looking at optimizing the query itself (e.g. Clarification of join order for creation of temporary tables), which took me from not being able to complete the query at all (with a 20 hr cap) to completing it but with time that's still not acceptable.

In experimenting, I found the following strange behavior that I'd like to understand: I want to do the query over a time range of 2 years. If I try to run it like that directly, then it still will not complete within the 10 min I'm allowing for the test. If I reduce it to the first 6 months of the range, it will complete pretty quickly. If I then incrementally re-run the query by adding a couple of months to the range (i.e. run it for 8 months, then 10 months, up to the full 2 yrs), each successive attempt will complete and I can bootstrap my way up to being able to get the full two years that I want.

I suspected that this might be possible due to caching of results by the MySQL server, but that does not seem to match the documentation:

If an identical statement is received later, the server retrieves the results from the query cache rather than parsing and executing the statement again.

http://dev.mysql.com/doc/refman/5.7/en/query-cache.html

The key word there seems to be "identical," and the apparent requirement that the queries be identical was reenforced by other reading that I did. (The docs even indicate that the comparison on the query is literal to the point that logically equivalent queries written with "SELECT" vs. "select" would not match.) In my case, each subsequent query contains the full range of the previous query, but no two of them are identical.

Additionally, the tables are updated overnight. So at the end of the day yesterday we had the full, 2-yr query running in 19 sec when, presumably, it was cached since we had by that point obtained the full result at least once. Today we cannot make the query run anymore, which would seem to be consistent with the cache having been invalidated when the table was updated last night.

So the questions: Is there some special case that allows the server to cache in this case? If yes, where is that documented? If not, any suggestion on what else would lead to this behavior?


Solution

  • We did some experimentation, including checking the effect from the system noted in the answer by @Solarflare. In our case, we concluded that the apparent caching was real, but it had nothing to do with MySQL at all. It was instead caused by the Linux disk cache. We were able to verify this in our case by manually flushing that cache after and before getting a result and comparing times.