securityprocessexecwmic

Sending passwords securely via command line without being exposed in ps/wmic (Windows,Unix)


We have an launcher application in Windows and Unix which execs (starts application using exec system call) an application like RDP, putty, MSSQL. In order to invoke it, we pass parameters to such as username, password, IP. Recently we found that, using wmic or ps one can find out what parameters have been passed it, thereby exposing sensitive information like passwords. Is there any way where we can either mask those passwords or hide the parameters all together. Note: My launcher gets parameters from a some other service, so asking for password after invoking application is not a option! Passwords have to be passed to application as parameter. Any solutions?


Solution

  • This is not possible (at least not on Linux, in a reliable way) to pass program arguments securely.

    A possible workaround is to pass the name of a file (or some other resource - e.g. some "reference" to some database entry) containing that password, or use some other inter-process communication facility (e.g. on Linux, fifo(7), shm_overview(7), pipe(7), unix(7), etc...) to pass these sensitive informations. You might also consider using environment variables (see environ(7) & getenv(3)).

    On Linux look also into proc(5) to understand what it is able to show about processes - thru /proc/1234/ for the process of pid 1234. Maybe you want seccomp facilities.

    On Unix, be aware of the setuid mechanism -tricky to understand-. Use it carefully (it is the basic block of most security or authentication machinery such as sudo and login) since a simple mistake could open a huge vulnerability.

    For a software written to work both on Unix & Windows, I recommend passing the password in some file (e.g. in /tmp/secretpassword) and giving the name/tmp/secretpassword (or some D:\foo\bar on Windows) of that file thru some program argument, and make sure to use wisely the file permission mechanisms to ensure that file is not readable by those who don't need it.