mysqlsqlexcept

MySQL EXCEPT equivalent


I am looking for MySQL equivalent or equivalents for the following query:

(select course_id
from section
where semester = 'Fall' and year= 2009)
except
(select course_id
from section
where semester = 'Spring' and year= 2010);

where the section table is:

+-----------+--------+----------+------+----------+-------------+--------------+
| course_id | sec_id | semester | year | building | room_number | time_slot_id |
+-----------+--------+----------+------+----------+-------------+--------------+
| BIO-101   | 1      | Summer   | 2009 | Painter  | 514         | B            |
| BIO-301   | 1      | Summer   | 2010 | Painter  | 514         | A            |
| CS-101    | 1      | Fall     | 2009 | Packard  | 101         | H            |
| CS-101    | 1      | Spring   | 2010 | Packard  | 101         | F            |
| CS-190    | 1      | Spring   | 2009 | Taylor   | 3128        | E            |
| CS-190    | 2      | Spring   | 2009 | Taylor   | 3128        | A            |
| CS-315    | 1      | Spring   | 2010 | Watson   | 120         | D            |
| CS-319    | 1      | Spring   | 2010 | Watson   | 100         | B            |
| CS-319    | 2      | Spring   | 2010 | Taylor   | 3128        | C            |
| CS-347    | 1      | Fall     | 2009 | Taylor   | 3128        | A            |
| EE-181    | 1      | Spring   | 2009 | Taylor   | 3128        | C            |
| EE-302    | 1      | Summer   | 2010 | Watson   | 327         | C            |
| FIN-201   | 1      | Spring   | 2010 | Packard  | 101         | B            |
| HIS-351   | 1      | Spring   | 2010 | Painter  | 514         | C            |
| MU-199    | 1      | Spring   | 2010 | Packard  | 101         | D            |
| PHY-101   | 1      | Fall     | 2009 | Watson   | 100         | A            |
+-----------+--------+----------+------+----------+-------------+--------------+

In other words I want to find all courses taught in the Fall 2009 semester but not in the Spring 2010 semester.


Solution

  • MySQL doesn't support except, so just use not exists or not in:

    select courseid
    from section sf
    where semester = 'Fall' and year = 2009 and not exists
          (select 1
           from section ss
           where sf.courseid = ss.courseid and ss.semester = 'Spring' and ss.year = 2010
          );
    

    (I prefer not exists because it has more intuitive support for NULL values.)

    This is not exact, because except removes duplicates. You could use select distinct, but I doubt that is really needed.