I was recently tweaking around with my DB and noticed that I made 5 migrations on top of my existing 2. So 7 in total, m1, m2, ..., m7. From these 5, I only want the latest version. So I was thinking I could remove m3, m4, m5, m6, m7 and migrate again, which will result in m3 that already contains the final version that I'm happy with. Now I have never done this before and was wondering what is the safest way to do it?
I'm using PHPStorm. Could I manually remove them (right click in PHPStorm then Delete) and then go to the command line and do php bin/console doctrine:migrations:migrate
? Or do I need to do php bin/console doctrine:schema:update
? Or is this really a bad idea?
No, generally you shouldn't do either of those. Let me start by clearing up what seems like a misconception: a migration doesn't contain a full database schema, only the queries necessary to bring the database from one version to the next. This system allows for database changes to be managed and versioned. So you should be starting to see some problems with this:
This might be acceptable during the design phase when you don't have any functionality yet. You can revert an individual migration using bin/console doctrine:migrations:execute --down <version>
. This is usually done while testing changes if adjustments need to be made. But usually when that change hasn't been committed yet.
Doctrine keeps track of migrations using a database table called migration_versions
. By naming them with a date, it can order them and apply them sequentially. Whenever a migration is executed, it adds the migration name to this table. When you roll it back, it deletes it from the table, along with the fields in the migration itself. Keep in mind that even though you can rollback a migration, it doesn't mean everything will be as it was. If a migration drops a column, the column will be recreated on rollback, but the data will be lost.
As for "can it be done"? Yes. If you really really want to, have read the documentation thoroughly and are aware of all this.
So, since your question is about merging migrations, let's tackle your actual options:
php bin/console doctrine:migrations:migrate
? No, this won't work. migrate
will apply available migrations. They won't be any and, as explained, the revisions will still be in the table and its changes applied.
php bin/console doctrine:schema:update
? This won't do anything either, since it will compare the model with the database and find that they match.
In any case, you will need to revert them first and then create an equivalent one. The command for that is doctrine:migrations:diff
. This will compare the model with the schema and generate a migration to get the database in sync. And for this to work you will need to execute --down
your migrations first, otherwise they won't be any changes, but potentially losing some data in the process.
If you work in a team, they will be seeing migrations disappear. Some might even be behind in the history and not applied all the migrations. This will soon become a management pain.
There is a rollup
command that (with my understanding and never actually used it) cleans stale migrations from the table, dumps a full schema and applies it. This will be your best bet, but be aware that this most like will delete your data.
You could also combine your migrations manually. They are just classes with an up
and down
methods. Combine all function bodies, apply the cleanup process and call it a day.
Now, if you want to do this it shouldn't be much of a problem. Just replace your outdated versions with your new one and warn everybody about it. But if what you want is to do as they never existed at all and keep a neat commit history, then that's when your teammates will potentially want to kill you, as it will involve rewriting history. When you do that, they will have to rebase all their work.
If you want to do it:
Reference for the console commands