c++stlpointersvectoriterator

Convert iterator to pointer?


I have a std::vector with n elements. Now I need to pass a pointer to a vector that has the last n-1 elements to a function.

For example, my vector<int> foo contains (5,2,6,87,251). A function takes vector<int>* and I want to pass it a pointer to (2,6,87,251).

Can I just (safely) take the iterator ++foo.begin(), convert it to a pointer and pass that to the function? Or use &foo[1]?

UPDATE: People suggest that I change my function to take an iterator rather than a pointer. That seems not possible in my situation, since the function I mentioned is the find function of unordered_set<std::vector*>. So in that case, is copying the n-1 elements from foo into a new vector and calling find with a pointer to that the only option? Very inefficient! It's like Shlemiel the painter, especially since i have to query many subsets: the last n-1, then n-2, etc. elements and see if they are in the unordered_set.


Solution

  • That seems not possible in my situation, since the function I mentioned is the find function of unordered_set<std::vector*>.

    Are you using custom hash/predicate function objects? If not, then you must pass unordered_set<std::vector<int>*>::find() the pointer to the exact vector that you want to find. A pointer to another vector with the same contents will not work. This is not very useful for lookups, to say the least.

    Using unordered_set<std::vector<int> > would be better, because then you could perform lookups by value. I think that would also require a custom hash function object because hash does not to my knowledge have a specialization for vector<int>.

    Either way, a pointer into the middle of a vector is not itself a vector, as others have explained. You cannot convert an iterator into a pointer to vector without copying its contents.