reactjsreact-hooksreact-suspense

How does React's useTransition avoid showing loading components?

In the docs: https://beta.reactjs.org/reference/react/useTransition#preventing-unwanted-loading-indicators

There's an example of a tab component that only shows up when it has finished loading all its data. Before it's finished, we still see the previously selected tab.

Something quirky is happening here, the TabButtons are aware of the new tab state and change their appearance, but in the rest of the JSX it seems we still work with the old value of tab - because we still see the previously selected tab, instead of no tab at all, or a spinner.

It seems that the tab state can have two values at the same time, in the same JSX statement.

See here, this is the code from the docs with a few things added to help in debugging: https://codesandbox.io/s/how-does-usetransition-work-n2vc9x?file=/App.js

Solution

  • Something quirky is happening here, the TabButtons are aware of the new tab state and change their appearance

    Not all of the TabButtons are updating at this point, just the one in which you called startTransition. Notice that About is still in bold during this time; it's not yet a button.

    What's happening is this:

    1. You call startTransition(() => { onClick(); });, and since onClick sets state, this requests a low priority rerender of App
    2. Before the low priority render, a high priority render happens just for the TabButton that called startTransition. During this render, It's still getting the old isActive prop which says it is not active, but useTransition returns true for isPending. As a result, it renders a <b className="pending">.
    3. Now the low priority render starts, rendering from App and down. This render includes the new tab state and passes isActive props to the tabs based on that. However, because the data in PostsTab is not yet loaded, this render has to abort. It falls back to the suspense, but because of the transition, suspense will keep whatever is already mounted (it doesn't use the loading fallback).
    4. Once the data is loaded another low priority render happens, and assuming this isn't interrupted the page updates with the new tab selected and the others deselected.